Support Us Button Widget

Supper clubs in Madison, WI

Two Old Fashioneds from Ishnala

Old Fashioneds at Ishnala Supper Club | Photo by @cateredcocktails608

Have you ever been to a traditional Wisconsin supper club?

Despite being a Midwestern staple, the first supper club was started in Beverly Hills, California by a Milwaukee native as prohibition was ending. Social diners began to pop up across the country. These dining institutions were destinations for fancy dinners, filling meals + friendly conversations.

Partly due to friendly Midwestern culture (ope, let me just squeeze past ya) + the agrarian nature of much of the Midwest, supper clubs stayed, even rising to infamy in some areas. Ishnala Supper Club near the Dells has over a 2-hour wait on the weekends.

So what makes a “true” supper club?

🏡 Location + atmosphere

  • On the outskirts of town, you’ll typically find supper clubs situated on a lake or near a forest. Usually run by families, these mom-and-pop-style establishments make it easy to strike up a conversation with your fellow diners.

🐟 Friday fish fry

  • Hearty entrees — from fish fry Fridays to prime rib Saturdays — are part of a classic meal.

🍸 Old Fashioned cocktail

  • Hold the bourbon. Every good meal starts with a good cocktail + supper clubs stick to the classics. Order an Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or Brandy Alexander.

🥩 Multiple courses

  • Wear your stretchy pants because you’re in for a multi-course meal. Traditional dinners start with tons of appetizers + classic cocktails, followed by meat-focused entrees and dessert carts.

Want to experience this Wisconsin classic? A few more places in town where you can sit + enjoy a generous and comforting meal.

🍽️ Kavanaugh’s Esquire Club | 1025 N. Sherman Ave.

🍽️ Toby’s Supper Club | 3717 S. Dutch Mill Rd.

🍽️ Delaney’s Steak, Seafood + Wine | 449 Grand Canyon Dr.

🍽️ The Harvey House | 644 W. Washington Ave.

🍽️ Tornado Steak House | 116 S. Hamilton St.

More from 608today
A turn of phrase here, a recognizable Madison nod there — these craft beers found around Mad City take local pride seriously.
From Monday, July 22 to Friday, July 26, 2024, we’re shining a spotlight on the vibrant drink scene in Madison; check out our map of local drink deals.
Explore these dog-friendly places in Madison — from places to eat, drink, shop, exercise, swim, and stay the night with your four-legged friends.
Volunteer with Healthy Food For All at local farmers’ markets.
If you’re trying to get more involved in the community, here’s where you can start.
Huxley Yards is set to open in 2026.
The Wisconsin DNR is urging boaters to be safe over the holiday.
The Partisan Primary is only a month away, so we’re brushing up on the absentee voting process and deadlines.
Once booming, now barren. Let’s take a peek at some malls of Madison’s past — plus hope for the future.