Supper clubs in Madison, WI

Two Old Fashioneds from Ishnala
Old Fashioneds at Ishnala Supper Club | Photo by @cateredcocktails608

Have you ever been to a traditional Wisconsin supper club? 

Despite being a Midwestern staple, the first supper club was started in Beverly Hills, California by a Milwaukee native as prohibition was ending. Social diners began to pop up across the country. These dining institutions were destinations for fancy dinners, filling meals + friendly conversations.

Partly due to friendly Midwestern culture (ope, let me just squeeze past ya) + the agrarian nature of much of the Midwest, supper clubs stayed, even rising to infamy in some areas. Ishnala Supper Club near the Dells has over a 2-hour wait on the weekends.

So what makes a “true” supper club

🏡 Location + atmosphere

  • On the outskirts of town, you’ll typically find supper clubs situated on a lake or near a forest. Usually run by families, these mom-and-pop-style establishments make it easy to strike up a conversation with your fellow diners.

🐟 Friday fish fry

  • Hearty entrees — from fish fry Fridays to prime rib Saturdays — are part of a classic meal. 

🍸 Old Fashioned cocktail

  • Hold the bourbon. Every good meal starts with a good cocktail + supper clubs stick to the classics. Order an Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or Brandy Alexander.

🥩 Multiple courses

  • Wear your stretchy pants because you’re in for a multi-course meal. Traditional dinners start with tons of appetizers + classic cocktails, followed by meat-focused entrees and dessert carts.

Want to experience this Wisconsin classic? A few more places in town where you can sit + enjoy a generous and comforting meal.

🍽️  Kavanaugh’s Esquire Club | 1025 N. Sherman Ave.

🍽️  Toby’s Supper Club | 3717 S. Dutch Mill Rd.

🍽️  Delaney’s Steak, Seafood + Wine | 449 Grand Canyon Dr.

🍽️  The Harvey House | 644 W. Washington Ave. 

🍽️  Tornado Steak House | 116 S. Hamilton St.